French Planning Services Inc.
   
 
Experience and Proven Expertise in areas of Natural, Social and Physical Resource Planning and Management
   
 

INSIGHTS:

Big Words on the Environment

ast night on the radio, someone announced in a deep scary voice "… the cumulative impacts are now surpassing environmental threshold limits and development is no longer sustainable". "Yikes" I thought, and then wondered if anyone really understood the message.

When environmental organizations, professionals, scientists and politicians talk about protecting our environment, they use big terms like "cumulative impact", "threshold limits" and "sustainable development". If you research these terms, you will find that they have a lot of fancy definitions that often use even bigger and more confusing words. So, I thought we needed a translation.

"Cumulative impact" is simply the end result of many small actions. Although cumulative impacts can be both good or bad, the term is usually applied in the negative sense. Here's an experiment to help you understand.

Take a cup of water, and fill it to about 3 cm from the top. Place it on something that is precious to you, like your favourite wooden dining room table that has been handed down to you from previous generations. Now slowly put a small stone or marble inside the cup, one at a time. Each time you do this, observe the change. When you look at the cup from far away, there does not appear to be much change. However, when you look at the cup up close, you notice the impact of adding stones. Add a few more stones until the cup is almost full. Every time you add a stone there is a change in the water level. The end result of these series of minor changes is called the "cumulative impact".

Truth or Dare

If you dare, add the remaining stones and note what happens. Every time you add a stone and there are no negative consequences, call that action "sustainable". The point at which the cup is about to over flow is called the "threshold" limit, and the action of adding stones beyond the threshold limit is no longer sustainable.


Let's examine the results of our experiment and ask ourselves a couple of questions. Is the end result sustainable to the maintenance of the wood finish of your grandparent's dining room table? Think what would happen if there were several similar experiments happening on the same table. Is the overall impact of these experiments good or bad for your table?

We can apply this experiment to real life. Call each one of your stones "development". If you get carried away with this you can give each stone a name like homes, cottages, golf courses, industry, businesses and roads. Pretend that your table is your favourite lake or river, and add a few more cups to represent "environmentally sensitive areas" such as wetlands, fish habitat areas, deer wintering yards, or rare and endangered species. If we apply the same process of gradually adding the "development" stones to the "sensitive environment" cups, do you think the wetlands, fish and wildlife habitat will survive? Will the impact of all these changes affect the future of your lake or neighbourhood? There is a definite similarity between your watermarked table and your favourite lake or river. We must be careful that our "cumulative impacts" are "sustainable" and do not cross "threshold limits". French Planning Services Inc. is not responsible for damage to your furniture. On second thought, perhaps you should try this experiment on your kitchen floor!

Randy P French

French Planning Services Inc
April 2000
 
     
 
_______________________________
 
Last Updated: May 26, 2005
 
Copyright French Planning Services Inc. ©2007.
FRENCH PLANNING SERVICES - 1016 Holiday Park Drive, Bracebridge, Ontario, Canada P1L 1W9
TEL: 705-646-0851 FAX: 705-645-4908


176353 Visitors to this site since January 1, 2005
 
Site Design, Hosting and Management by
GREAT NORTHERN TECHNICAL SERVICES